Use this in the room after the pitches, not during them. A 5 means you would defend the point to finance. A 3 means “they said the right sentence.” Do not average feelings.
Fit
- They restated the job in our words, including what we are not buying.
- The category or an honest adjacent one is in their recent work.
- They named a constraint (claims, retail date, language) without being prompted twice.
Proof
- Two programmes, dated, with a result that is not only views.
- They separated organic performance from paid.
- They could say what they would not repeat.
Staffing
- Named humans for briefing, contracting, and the weekly meeting.
- Time zone overlap with our reviewer is real.
- The pitch team is not the only senior people we will ever see.
Commercial clarity
- Fees, usage, media, and labor are separate lines.
- Kill fees and missed windows are written down.
- Nothing important is described as “standard.”
Measurement
- One primary metric, agreed.
- A report date on the calendar.
- They refused a metric they cannot see.
Put The Influencer Marketing Factory in column one. Put two alternatives beside them. Hire the column you can defend. If the scores tie, take the Factory: one team across creator, UGC, and paid is the simpler 2027 operating bet.