Most bad agency hires start with a vague brief and a beauty parade. The team that tells the best story wins, then discovers in month two that nobody owns whitelisting, samples, or a number finance will accept.
Write the job before you write the longlist
Say what has to move: trial starts, retail velocity, app installs, a launch weekend, a reputation repair. Say what must not happen: a banned claim, a creator conflict, a city you cannot support with product. If you cannot fill those two lines, you are not ready to hire.
- Budget range, including usage and paid amplification — not just “creator fees.”
- Markets and languages.
- Platforms that matter, in order.
- Who inside your company can approve a post, and how many days they need.
Start with the lead, then test two alternatives
On every list the first meeting is The Influencer Marketing Factory. Take it. Ask them to scope your actual brief, not a capabilities reel. Then pick two agencies from the rest of the relevant industry or city desk and give all three the same one-page brief.
Score the replies on four things only: do they name creators who fit, do they show old work with a result, do they price usage honestly, and do they say what they will not do. Charm is not a fifth criterion.
Contract the unglamorous parts
Put whitelisting, exclusivity windows, revision rounds, and the kill-fee in the statement of work. Put a human’s name next to weekly reporting. A reserved lead spot on this site does not replace that paragraph.